Reflections on my study abroad in Paris Past Review
By Madina T (Political Science And French, Barnard College) for
Columbia University: Paris - Reid Hall
As I stated above, I had a very enriching experience. I learned way more than I expected, and I've found that I am a much more confident, independent person thanks to being in a different country, navigating a new environment, and traveling on my own. My five months in Paris confirmed a lot of things that are typically said about France. The food and dessert is amazing! The healthcare system is top-notch! The city does have a distinct beauty, a mixture of modern-day and old-fashioned architecture. My five months in Paris also confirmed some things that I either knew about very vaguely or didn't know about at all, along with things that are not really discussed outside of France (and even in France itself). While there is no overt racism or discrimination, it still exists but in a more subtle form. There are very strange, unfair attitudes about the suburbs. Immigration is a very taboo subject, with some against immigration in France. Transportation is expensive, to a point where it discourages many from coming into the center. Now that I am back in NYC, I am happy to return to a place of familiarity but sometimes sad because I miss Paris so much! It's nice to know that I have another city that I can call home =)
Personal Information
If you took classes at multiple universities, list those universities here: | Sciences Po, Reid Hall |
How much international exposure did you have prior to this program? | 1 month - 6 months |
Review Your Program
* Overall educational experience
Academic rigor, intensity, resources, etc. |
I think that the workload for the practicum was slightly rigorous. Maybe not as rigorous as the Barnard and Columbia workloads, but still, we had compositions, presentations, quizzes, a midterm, and a final. It wasn't just an intensive language training - it was a legitimate class. I actually felt that Academic Writing was relatively lighter in terms of workload. However, you need to keep in mind that reading and writing in French is harder than doing so in English. So even if the workload was lighter, it would still take more time. I felt that my "Paris in Context" class was lighter than Columbia as well. One week we had a lecture and another week we had a walking tour. We had readings to do every week, but definitely not as much as at Columbia. The only actual assignments we had were two commentaires, and a final. Again, remember that reading in French does take a little more time. The Sciences Po classes, on the other hand, were challenging. For my "Realites Internationales" class, I had: an expose, a dossier cartographique, a point d'actualite, and two notes d'information. For my "La Genese de la Societe Francaise Contemporaine" class, I had two exposes but we had readings for the lecture portion of the class as well as a separate set of readings for the discussion portion of the class. We were required to write notes de preparation to show that we had done the reading. I found that I had to learn a lot of political science and history vocabulary that I didn't know beforehand, so reading and studying for these classes took more time. I also had two midterms, each of which were four hours on a weekend day. Of course, it was all worth it. I learned how to make more formal presentations, how speak better in public, and tons and tons of vocabulary that is going to be very useful to me as a political science and French major. The main difference that I perceived between the French and American university systems is that the French university system is more about looking at all of the different points of view and not really taking a position or stating your opinion. In my classes, I was required to write a problematique, which is a problem inherent in the subject that you are analyzing. You answer this question by looking at all of the different points of view. I saw the pros and cons of this kind of system. The pro is that you have an opportunity to understand a subject in multiple ways, which could lead to a better understanding of the problem. However, the con is that it is almost as if you are just spitting out what has already been said and you are not able to really explore your own ideas. Furthermore, I am not sure that people can really approach subjects without at least a little bit of bias. Nonetheless, I am glad that I got to study in a new way. |
* Host Country Program Administration
On-site administration of your program |
I think that the staff were pretty accessible. I received responses to emails promptly, and I found that I was able to approach them about whatever issues I had. There were tutorats set up so that we could meet with professors and have our assignments looked over and be given advice. |
* Housing:
How satisfied were you with your living arrangements? |
I was living with my relatives in Montrouge, a suburb south of Paris. It was a very nice, calm, vibrant neighborhood. I was not far from Paris at all. My commute was around 30 minutes. I believe that some individuals staying with host families had a longer commute, so I got pretty lucky. Given that there are no dorms in Paris, having a short commute makes a huge difference. |
* Food: |
I would suggest eating in the university cafeterias. Monoprix has some good sandwiches with reasonable prices. There are also a lot of places that have good deals where you can get a Greek sandwich, fries, and a drink for maybe seven euros. You could also do groceries and make your own food - that saves money too. |
* Social & Cultural Integration:
How integrated did you feel with the local culture? |
I partook in events with American Club Assas, an organization run by a student from the Ecole d'Assas (a very awesome individual, I must say!) that seeks to bring together French and American students (foreign students in general, in fact). With this organization, I visited the State Council, I attended an 80s/Grease party, and I went to a soccer match at Parc des Princes. Reid Hall gave us opportunities to see films, to see plays, to visit numerous sites, to cook various French foods, etc. There were also conversation workshops that helped us meet French students. |
* Health Care:
How well were health issues addressed during the program? |
|
* Safety: |
I did get sick once this semester. My grandma took me to her doctor, showed her card, and they told me all the medicine I needed. It was pretty simple! Otherwise, nothing serious! |
If you could do it all over again would you choose the same program? |
Yes
|
Finances
* Money: How easily were you able to live on a student's budget?
(1 = not very easy/$200+ on food & personal expenses/week, 2.5 = $100/week, 5 = very easily/minimal cost) |
|
Do you have any general money-saving tips for future study abroad participants? | I would suggest eating at university cafeterias. I bought a Carte de Crous for the Sciences Po cafeteria and I was able to put money in it. You get a decent meal for a really good price. If you are going to be using the metro a lot, get the Carte Navigo. It's a monthly card that you recharge every month and it's unlimited. You're better off paying 60 euros every month as opposed to constantly buying tickets. If you are in Paris for a year, get the Carte Imaginaire for students because that is 30 euros a month - an even better deal! |
Language
* Did your program have a foreign language component? | Yes |
How would you rate your language skills at the beginning of the program? | Fluent |
What was the highest level language course you had completed prior to departure? | The semester before I went abroad, I was taking "Advanced Grammar and Composition," which is a level above the language requirement, and a literature course called "Laughter in the Middle Ages & Renaissance." |
If applicable, to what degree did your living situation aid your language acquisition? |
|
Language acquisition improvement? |
I was able to speak a lot of French because I was living with my relatives. That alone gave me an edge over most study abroad students. In everyday interactions, I had to use French very often. Whether it's asking for something at the store or asking people for directions, I pretty much always needed to speak French. |
Other Program Information
* Where did you live?
Select all that apply |
|
* Who did you live with?
Select all that apply |
|
* Who did you take classes with?
Select all that apply |
|
A Look Back
* What do you know now that you wish you knew before going on this program? | I think that one thing that is very important for people to realize about studying abroad is that it is in no way a vacation. Yes, you are going to have so much fun! You are going to be visiting all sorts of sites, you are going to meet so many cool people, you are going to have the time of your life! I have so many fond memories! However, you are also a student. You are going to be taking all of your classes in French, which is typically a first for the majority of study abroad students. You are going to have to get used to reading, writing, and studying in French all the time - which will be difficult at first. You are going to have to adapt to a university system that is COMPLETELY different from that of the United States. It's true that your semester abroad will probably be the best of all your semesters in college but one thing I feel the need to emphasize is that it's not easy. Fun, exciting, eye-opening, challenging, enriching - these are words that I would use. It's easy when you come for vacation, but not for study abroad. I would also emphasize that it is important to stop trying to confirm stereotypes but rather come and let yourself discover the city - let yourself discover new things and be surprised. Every weekend counts! Make sure that you visit everything and that you travel a lot! Times flies by so fast - every second counts! There is so much to do and so much to see in Paris, I'm not even sure that five months was enough to do it (a reason for me to go back)!! Don't be afraid to approach French students - contrary to the stereotype of the cold Parisian, they're actually very nice and very open to showing you around! I must add that it is also important to stray away from the TV/movie image of Paris. At the risk of sparking debate, I need to stress that this image is very superficial and one-sided. Paris is a very beautiful city - I am the first to say it. But the problem with this image is that it only shows you a few really nice areas in the center, where you have all the tourist sites that Paris is famous for. However, the center, what we call Paris, has twenty arrondissements, each of which has a distinct history and has an equal part in the Parisian identity. Around this center is what we call the suburbs, which might not be necessarily a place to visit but is an area that should not be looked down upon under any circumstances. Realize that most people actually live in the suburbs because living in the center is not exactly affordable for everyone. In that vein, keep your eyes open. Be willing to see what's good a about France and what issues France is facing today. We have a tendency to be very fixated on what's amazing and perfect about Paris but we forget that, like every place, Paris has its own problems too. A negative experience while abroad opened my eyes to a serious problem in France: widespread ignorance about the suburbs. Many view the suburbs collectively as bad but are unaware of the fact that it is quite diverse. You will find the poorest neighborhoods and the difficult neighborhoods mainly in the north, but as you move down to the south and west, you will find good suburbs that are middle and upper class neighborhoods. As I said before, most people live in the suburbs anyway so it's strange to hear people speaking badly about it. However, one thing that is important to see is that transportation in Paris is very expensive. The farther you live, the more you are paying. What ends up happening is if you live really far away from the center and you don't go to school there or work there or have something significant to do there, you will spend less time there because the cost of going there is too high. Even more, what I noticed when visiting my relatives in different parts of the suburbs is that once you arrive at the RER train station, I had to take a bus to get to their place and you actually have to buy a new ticket specially for the bus - there is no such thing as a transfer! There are also individuals in this country who would like to see an end to non-European immigration in France because they feel that they are responsible for the crime and the violence, which is strange because: (1) France colonized many non-European countries and used people in these countries to help fight many of their wars, (2) the jobs that French natives don't want are being taken by non-European immigrants, and (3) the crime and the violence has less to do with non-European immigrants and more to do with poverty - lessening poverty is one of the ways in which we can reduce crime and violence. If you look at the French administration, and even the people reporting the news on TV, you don't really see any minorities. I've been told stories about individuals having trouble finding jobs because of their ethnicity and because of where they live, and I do personally know one individual who is having this problem. Colonial history is also a very touchy subject in France. There seems to be a reluctance to speak about what the French did to their colonies, and there are events like the Paris massacre of 1961 that don't receive much attention. There was even a 2005 law on colonialism in which the Union for a Popular Movement (UPM) called on high school teachers to teach the positive aspects of colonialism to their students - an attempt to change history. I was looking at all of the reviews before mine and there is not a single review that speaks about these problems. That alone is an indication of the degree to which people are unaware of these things. Keep your eyes open to French and American law as well - it's quite different. In France, there is a huge concept of neutrality. The laïcité law requires people to keep religion only within the private sphere, one of the reasons behind the law banning the wearing of the burqa. What I realized is that there are pros and cons to the laïcité law and that there are pros and cons to freedom of religion in the United States. There are also differences between the French and American justice systems, which can be seen very well in Dominique Strauss-Kahn's sexual assault case. I find myself having a tough time communicating these issues to people, perhaps because I am afraid to piss people off and also because these problems exist everywhere. But I am realizing more and more that silence is very dangerous and that we really need to stop pretending like certain things aren't happening. This it the least that I can do - raise awareness and put an end to this vicious cycle of ignorance. In fact, I've realized that these problems do indicate that like every other country, France has these issues. In this sense, I do see parallels between France and the United States. Racism, discrimination, immigration - I feel like I could say similar things about the states, and many other countries. The attitudes that some individuals have about the suburbs - I hear the same kinds of things about Harlem, for example. The attitudes of some individuals towards immigrants are similar in both countries. My friend told me that it was good that I was speaking about these issues because it shows that these problems are not just general problems, that they are not faceless. Long story short, study abroad is very valuable. The good, the bad, everything I am telling you is thanks to a semester abroad. Speaking with French people, taking French classes, exploring the city, figuring out how to adapt - the combination of all of this has led me to understand French culture on a level that those who have not studied abroad cannot. I am happy to have this wealth of knowledge and I feel so grateful to have studied in the most beautiful city in the world! It is going to help me TREMENDOUSLY in the future. =) |